Day 6: And then there were five Options

[Josh]

INH was too loyal. He had to be... disposed of.

INH was human. Tomorrow ends... when I get around to it. Possibly some time on Saturday at this rate. In any case, have night orders in and ready if needs be.

[Lu-Tze]

Trollslayer was my top choice for number 3, honest. Well done I guess Jim?

[Insert Name Here]

Dammit. I was finally starting to get into it, too

[Robert Trollslay...]

And I would have gotten away with it! If it wasn't for that meddling Kidz!

[Inflammable Jim]

*dusts hands*

Okay. Now I think there is an awful lot we can salvage from how people have reacted to Lu, and the people who've gone for Trollslayer. However I have some work to do right now so I'll try and say these things tomorrow evening.

[Girdag]

OK.

Still alive:

CAD
C-Dave
Dustbin13
Girdag
Jim - HUMAN

Two wolves.

Hmm. My suspicion is that CAD is one of them, will re-read past threads and post more once I've had the time to build up a decent case that's more than gut feeling.

EDIT: OK, I'd be very surprised if CAD and C-Dave were both wolves, given that C-Dave's been gunning for him in both of the last two days. Not certain which is which, but knowing that I'm human, the logical conclusion is that Dustbin13 is the wolfish brethren of one of them. This does make XYZIA's comments on Day 4 more interesting - CAD and Dustbin13 as the final wolves, anyone?

[Clearasday]

Girdag, I am a human. And if Dustbin is a wolf, that does not make me his partner. I've voted for him on many occasions, and I will be happy to again. But I'm not going to just because for some reason you think we're a team.

Xyzia was wrong. Its in his behaviour to be paranoid of me since I've manipulated him a few times. But I've not manipulated anyone for games, nobody trusts me anymore. If you lynch Dustbin just because Xyzia had some wild unproved theory, I will lynch you. Just saying. You're not exactly human for me.

C-dave, why have you wanted me dead both days, answer

Jim, say something of use, good job on trollslayer, retarded job on Lu.


This is however strange, because I actually thought Dustbin was a lover, since he texted me asking 'could a wolf be a lover?'.


And now for my case, I've had enough of getting back to find C-Dave voting for me. Xyzia did it because he misunderstood something Dustbin said. Kidz did it because I said he was being silly voting for Lu. C-Dave, you've never had a reason. I was on to you the first day, so you kept your head down. Now you just come back on every day to vote me. If you're not a wolf, you deserve to lose for playing absolutely terribly and giving the wolf team the win.

Clearasday for some reason decided I was worth goading earlier in the game but has completely dropped that, obviously when it got no traction with other players.

What you say about me on day 4

But then you suddenly change to defend Xyzia:

I don't want to see XYZIA die personally. So I'll go for Clearasday.

Trying to sway the vote into lynching me. it turns out both Xyzia and I are human, as I actually thought, Because I wasn't voting for Xyzia at that point. But you nearly godamn had me lynched if Kidz hadn't come in to help.

Day 5:

To be honest, I'm still waiting for you to explain your early votes for me so making demands of me is a bit rich. For the record though, I initially voted for retracted, even though I never got round to making it - Jim and do so again today, but when it was clear that voting Jim wasn't going to save XYZIA I switched to someone who already had a vote to try and engineer a tie. Why you? Well, I was partly pressed for time, meaning I had to choose and given your early votes for me you were the first name I came to. Your continuing assertions about Lu also worry me. As Trollslayer says we have no proof that Lu is a human. Kidz and Kramer being so inclined does not absolve Lu. The fact that he didn't do anything to help save Kramer doesn't look kindly upon him, but you seemed more inclined to believe that Kidz was partially to blame for not saving him. You've also been quite cocky about how the wolves ploy of not killing was going to fail. Hmm.

Clearasday

Again you come in with voting for Jim (like you did on day 4, is he the other human? Is Dustbin or Girdag your partner then?) But then switch to me because I'm 'cocky'? I haven't acted cocky, I'm not cocky. I haven't killed a wolf yet. Nobody follows my cases, I'm not cocky. You're cocky. You sit there doing nothing and then you vote me. You're literally the most obvious wolf I've ever seen. When I said I had to go out and I couldn't read the thread, your response was 'the whole 3 posts made since I last posted'. Everything you've said has been an unprovoked attack on me.
Your vote on me also came just after INH voted for Trollslayer, which proves you wanted to get me lynched in his stead when I wasn't around, so that you could win. Die. C-Dave
Good game.

[Clearasday]

Also, I'm going out, so attack me all you want, but kill C-dave.

[Carlisle Dave]

I don't even know where to begin answering that. Oh wait, yes I do. Retracted - Clearasday

[Inflammable Jim]

I mean I think Dustbin is the most human of you because he's actually put thought into his votes, and reading them they feel genuine.

(Josh can we have an extension to this day?)

[Carlisle Dave]

Okay, leaving aside the personal stuff, I'll do my best to respond.

C-dave, why have you wanted me dead both days, answer

Okay, can you please stop being so rude. I'm getting a bit fed up of your constant demands for me to explain my votes, especially when I laid out my reasons yesterday for you.

I was on to you the first day, so you kept your head down. Now you just come back on every day to vote me.

You mean with the votes you made for no apparent reason and which you suddenly dropped from making with again no reason. Votes which, despite my asking (note asking, not demanding) why you had made them, you've not really mentioned your reasons behind.

Clearasday for some reason decided I was worth goading earlier in the game but has completely dropped that, obviously when it got no traction with other players.

What you say about me on day 4

But then you suddenly change to defend Xyzia:

I don't want to see XYZIA die personally. So I'll go for Clearasday.

Trying to sway the vote into lynching me. it turns out both Xyzia and I are human, as I actually thought, Because I wasn't voting for Xyzia at that point. But you nearly godamn had me lynched if Kidz hadn't come in to help.

Okay, I can't quite see the point you're getting at here. I didn't want XYZIA to die so went for someone I thought may be a wolf who already had a vote to try and save him. Interesting how my attempts to save a human are considered wolfish but you're bigging up Kidz for helping to kill same human.

Again you come in with voting for Jim (like you did on day 4, is he the other human? Is Dustbin or Girdag your partner then?)

Actually, I never voted for Jim, though it was my intention to do so. As I was writing the post, answering your demands that I explain my actions, I came to the conclusion that you were much more lupine. Hence the vote.

But then switch to me because I'm 'cocky'? I haven't acted cocky, I'm not cocky.

I didn't say you were being cocky in general, just with regard to the lack of wolf kills. This sounds fairly cocky to me:

They can play it this way if they want to, it seems to me that all it will achieve is lots of seerings, since Kidz seems to be a confirmed human and they didn't kill him. We should just carry on lynching, (obviously not getting the seer) and watch the wolves realise why this is the most fail elaborate plot ever.

Effectively to me you're calling the wolves stupid there.

Everything you've said has been an unprovoked attack on me.

Unprovoked attack? I've not actually attacked you. I've said you seemed a bit cocky about one particular thing and explained the reasons why I thought you were a wolf. As for unprovoked those two early votes for no good reason didn't happen then? So even if I was attacking you, there was provocation.

Your vote on me also came just after INH voted for Trollslayer, which proves you wanted to get me lynched in his stead when I wasn't around, so that you could win.

You also voted after INH for someone who wasn't Trollslayer. I don't understand your point. Voting for you didn't put you in the lead or anything and when I did vote for you, you hadn't said that you weren't going to be around.

Anyway, there is my refutation to your points.

[Inflammable Jim]

Girdag

Too noncommittal, too much words, too little substance.

[Carlisle Dave]

On the advice of Jim Girdag

God I hope Jim's not a wolf.

[Josh]

[I]Suddenly, a cohort of legionairres burst in, immediately spearing the very rebellious Girdag through the chest! Loyalist scum Jim and Clearasday help to overcome the remainder smuggly while, in his palace, Caesar laughs a mocking laugh at the pitiful insurrectionist failure.

Wolves win!

[Carlisle Dave]

So I voted for the two last wolves in the space of a single post yesterday? Hohum.

Well played Jim, you deserved it, though the events yesterday were somewhat odd.

Also, well GM'd Josh!

[Carlisle Dave]

I'm actually quite annoyed that Jim managed to talk me round. I knew CaD was a wolf but was never wholly convinced on Girdag. Ah well, after Day 5 where it made no sense for Jim to kill a wolf if he was one, I was probably going to go with him anyway.

[Inflammable Jim]

Sorry I didn't have time for more than a couple of hours of play each day so I was hurried and whatnot. Can I ask what was going on with the seerings?

[Insert Name Here]

Jim, you cad.

[Inflammable Jim]

sorry, sorry

[Josh]

Lacked a certain pizzazz that game. Ah well.

Thanks for playing all

[Carlisle Dave]

Dare I say it that TWG may have run its course?

[Josh]

I think I may agree.

[Masked Dave]

Hmm, yeah. I was about to post a defence of why we should keep going, but I realised I don't actually mind either way...

[Robert Trollslay...]

Play on sekrit guys, you need fresh minds to probe-

http://www.sekritforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=113240#p113240 Jim's got an ace ruleset

[Inflammable Jim]

YEAH